Wednesday, September 8, 2010
Nina Simone: Feelings
Yeah. That Feelings.
That erstwhile cocktail lounge cheese brick that's but a thinly disguised reworking of Irving Berlin's Blue Skies. (The thief in this case was French composer Louis Gasté who "wrote" the melody in 1956, though he had to sue Morris Albert to get credit. It was Albert's English version that was the international hit.) "Sentimental sewage" is how composer Richard Strauss once described the music of his peer Rachmaninoff and it'd be easy to make the same assessment here. A tune practically manufactured for a wussy, weepy warble. But in this you'd be wrong. Whatever you once believed about Feelings, cast that away; Simone's trenchant evangelism will surely shatter such naive notions. There's truth in all that cheese and she's going to tell it: It took a profound and abysmal pain to compose a song like Feelings and it deserves our respect, not ridicule. A point of fact she must stop in mid-bar to punctuate. Don't laugh, she says and then proceeds to forget, misremember, and reimagine the song in her own words—some completely off the top of her head as you'll see. Words that push this once squishy ditty from the realms of the pathetic to the suicidal. ("I wished I never lived this long.") Eventually this leads to a little Bach-like interlude to throw a couple of rivets into the lid for closing. She finishes with a big Over the Rainbow type coda, a few last words, and then, The End.
Read the original lyrics and discover only a mere suggestion of what Simone offers here. In terms of evolution, Albert's version had barely yet crawled out of the slime.
Nina Simone was never one to back off from the cloying pop tune. Look through her catalog (To Love Somebody, Alone Again (Naturally), Mr. Bojangles, Angel of the Morning, and on and on) and notice it's loaded with the stuff. For her, it's as if covering these songs were a badge of honor. For less capable talents mining this kind of Top 40 would only diminish the fire of their better work. (Ever heard Sinatra take on Mrs. Robinson and Tie a Yellow a Ribbon?) But not for Simone. Look at the way she looks out into the audience—through them really—like a Harvard professor trying to explain Moby Dick to inner-city middle schoolers. She's on a mission and the message is what matters; If the audience can't receive it, well, she's only too happy to play the message for herself.
What kind of artist can take a sludgey over-worn nugget like this and raise it aloft on such an exalted altar? A genius? I think so.
Posted by Deiter at 11:27 AM